| lyK: ieMtrnYWt Auqy pMjfbI dI vrqoN dIaF smwisafvF rfjpfl isMG, kotkpUrf awj dy dOr ivwc ieMtrnYwt vYsy qF hr BfeIcfry leI igafn pRfpqI, siBafcfrk afdfn pRdfn aqy afpsI qflmyl df aihm sfDn hY pr pMjfbIaF vrgy globlI BfeIcfry leI qF ies dI aihmIaq bhuq hI ijLafdf hY. sfrI dunIaF ivwc PYly hoey pMjfbIaF ivwc afpsI sFJ dIaF qMdF nUM kfiem rwKx leI ieMtrnYwt bhuq hI mhwqvpUrn sfDn hY. ieMtrnYwt rfjsI hwdF, Dfrimk PurmfnF, srkfrI sYNsrisLpF, BUgoilk dUrIaF aqy hor sfry aiVwikaF nUM qoV ky jfxkfrI aqy gwlbfq df sfDn bx igaf hY . ieMtrnYwt qy pMjfbIaF duafrf clfey jf rhy cYt-rUmF aqy PormF ivwc hr dysL dy pMjfbI krdy, suwK-sFd puwCdy aqy bihs ivcfr krdy dyKy jf skdy hn . gwlF mfrn leI ieMtrnYwt dy cYtrUm ivwc jfx leI GroN cwl ky ipMz dy swQ ivwc jfx nfloN vI Gwt smF lgdf hY. pr pMjfbI BfsLf nUM ijQy Dfrimk aqy rfjsI vMzF df sfhmxf krnf ipaf AuQy ilpI df mslf vI pMjfbI BfsLf dy ivkfs aqy pMjfbI lokF dI afpsI sFJ leI bhuq vwzf mslf bixaf irhf hY. ieh mslf kMipAUtr aqy ieMtrnYwt dy dOr ivwc vI kfiem hY ikAuNik kMipAUtr Auqy ivcfrF df afdfn pRdfn muwK qOr qy ilKqI rUp ivwc hI huMdf hY. pMjfbI ilKx leI ijQy pihlF gurmuKI aqy sLfhmuKI ilpIaF dI vrqoN ho rhI sI AuQy hux ieMtrnYwt Auwqy romn ilpI (aMgryjNI awKrF vflI) dI vrqoN vI bhuq ho rhI hY. Kfs kr ilKqI rUp ivwc afpsI gwlbfq krn leI bxy cYtrUmF ivwc qF pUrI qrHF romn ilpI dI hI vrqoN huMdI hY. ieMtrnYwt Auwqy romn ilpI gurmuKI aqy sLfhmuKI dohF dy mukfbly brfbr dI qIsrI iDr vjoN sfhmxy af rhI hY. asl ivwc qknIk acyq hI aYnI qbdIlI kr idMdI hY sfnUM pqf hI nhIN lgdf ik aYnf kuJ vfpr igaf hY. ijvyN mobfeIl Pon Auwqy aYs[aYm[aYs[ rfhIN jo sunyihaF df afdfn pRdfn kIqf jFdf hY AuhnF ivwc qF pMjfbI iPkiraF nUM pihlF hI romn awKrF ivwc iliKaf jf irhf hY . sfzI nOjvfn pIVHI ies dI pUrI qrF afdI ho cuwkI hY aqy Aus nUM romn awKrF ivwc ilKx jF pVHn lwigaF kuJ vI Eprf nhIN lgdf. ijwQoN qwk ikqfbF jF ipRMt mIzIey df sbMD hY qF BfrqI pMjfbI afpxIaF ikqfbF,rsfly gurmuKI ilpI ivwc aqy pfiksqfnI pMjfbI sLfhmuKI ivwc pRkfisLq krvfAuNdy af rhy hn. ies nfl cfhy dovF pMjfbF ivckfr iewk dIvfr df aihsfs qF huMdf sI pr ikAuNik muwK qOr qy BfrqI ikqfbF, rsfly, aKbfr BfrqI pMjfb dy jF hor dysLF ivwc gey hoey BfrqI mUl dy pMjfbIaF ny hI pVHny huMdy sn aqy sLfhmuKI ivwc ilKIaF ilKqF pfiksqfnI pMjfb ivwc jfxIaF huMdIaF sn ies leI afm pfTk dy mn ivwc ilpI dy vKryvyN vflf ieh aihsfs bhuqf qIbr nhIN huMdf sI. pr ieMtrnYwt qy iliKaf hoieaf hr sLbd sfrI dunIaF vfsqy huMdf hY ijQy mulkF jF DrmF dIaF vMzIaF df koeI arQ nhIN rih jFdf, AuQy ieko BfsLf dIaF vwKo-vwKrIaF ilpIaF hox df mslf bhuq cuBdf hY. ies msly df iek hwl qF qknIkI qOr qy krn dI koisLsL kIqI geI hY. aijhy sfPtvyar bxfey gey hn ijs nfl iek kmFz dy ky gurmuKI ivwc ilKI gwl nUM sLfhmuKI ivwc aqy sLfhmuKI ivwc ilKy nUM gurmuKI ivwc bdilaf jf skdf hY. aijhf sfPtvyar ikrpfl isMG pnUM ny bxfieaf hY aqy sLfied pfiksqfn ivwc vI aijhIaF koisLsLF kIqIaF jf rhIaF hn, pr ieh ajy qwk hrmn ipafrf nhIN ho sikaf . sLfied ies df iek kfrn ieh vI hovy ik purfxI pIVHI dy igxqI dy kuJ lokF nUM Cwz ky bfkI BfrqI pMjfbIaF leI sLfhmuKI ivwc aqy pfiksqfnI pMjfbIaF leI gurmuKI ivwc iliKaf 'kflf awKr BYNs brfbr' vflI gwl hI huMdI hY. kMipAUtr dI kmFz rfhIN cfhy ilpI dI qbdIlI ho jFdI hY pr kI dUsrI ilpI ivwc vfkeI AuhI gwl ilKI geI hY ies dI ilKx vfly nUM qswlI nhIN huMdI. ijvyN duBfsLIey rfhIN gwlbfq krky Auh svfd nhIN afAuNdf Ausy qrHF Kud qoN nf pVHI jf skx vflI ilpI ivwc afpxI gwl ilK ky qswlI nhIN huMdI. dUjf kfrn ieh vI ho skdf hY ieh sfPtvyar afm lokF dI phuMc ivwc hI nf hovy ikAuNik sfzy qF AuhI sfPtvyar pRcilq huMdf hY ijs df pfeIrytz rUp afsfnI nfl imldf hovy. KYr iesy qrHF df iek sfPtvyar pMjfbI XUnIvristI dy zf[gurpRIq isMG lihl ny iqafr kIqf hY ijs rfhIN romn awKrF ivwc ilKI gwl nUM gurmuKI ilpI ivwc qbdIl kIqf jf skdf hY. Audfhrx vjoN romn awKrF ivwc Tuhada ki hal hai ilKy nUM ieh sfPtvyar "quhfzf kI hfl hY?" ivwc qbdIl kr dyvygf. ieh vI kfPI kMm dI cIjL hY ikAuNik pwCmI dysLF ivwc bYTy nvIN pIVHI dy pMjfbI bolcfl qF jfxdy hn pr Auh gurmuKI ilpI ivwc ilKx qoN asmrQ huMdy hn aqy jo gurmuKI ivwc ilK skdy huMdy hn Auh gurmuKI awKrF dI tfeIp nhIN jfxdy huMdy. dovF hflqF ivwc hI Auh afpxI gwl kI-borz qy tfeIp krky nhIN kr skdy sn ijs df hwl ieh sfPtvyar krygf. ies qoN awgy mslf hY pMjfbI PONts df. ies ivwc vI do qrHF dy PONts cwl rhy hn -PonYitk aqy rimMgtn. rimMgtn PONts Auh hn ijnHF ivwc awKr pMjfbI tfeIp msLIn dy kI-borz dy ihsfb nfl nwpx qy pYNdy hn. tfeIp jfxn vfly jfxdy hn ik tfeIp msLIn Auwqy awKr lVIvfr nhIN huMdy blik AuNglF dI shUlq vfsqy vwD aqy Gwt vrqoN dy anusfr huMdy hn. Audfhrx vjoN ies ivwc kI-borz dI dUsrI lfeIn dy KwibAuN dUsrI kI nwpy qoN "q" awKr pvygf (ijQy aMgryjLI df "aYs" awKr pYNdf hY) aKbfrF, rsfilaF aqy ikqfbF Cfpx vfilaF vwloN iehI PONt vrqy jFdy hn. pMjfbI tfeIp jfxn vfly ies qy rPqfr nfl kMm kr skdy hn ikAuNik pMjfbI tfeIp isKdy smyN AuhnF dIaF AuNglF iesy anusfr aiBafsI hoeIaF huMdIaF hn. sqluj, rxjIq, aMimRq, pRfeIm-jf, gurmuKI afid PONt iesy iksm dy hn. pr pMjfbI tfeIp bhuq QoVHy lok jfxdy hn jdik kMipAUtr df psfrf bhuq ho igaf hY. pMjfbI tfeIp nf jfxdy lok vI pMjfbI ilKx leI kMipAUtr dI vrqoN kr skx, ies vfsqy PonYitk PONt bxfey gey. iehnF ivwc aMgryjLI dy awKrF dI DunI dy anusfr pMjfbI dy awKr pYNdy hn. Audfhrx vjoN kI-borz qy aMgryjLI df aYs awKr nwipaf "s", bI qoN "b", XU qooN aONkV, isLPt XU qoN dulYNkV afid awKr pYNdy hn. ieh isstm pMjfbI tfeIp nf jfxn vfilaF leI vDIaf hY aqy bfhrly dysLF ivwc vsy pMjfbI iesy dI vwD vrqoN krdy hn . aMimRq ilpI-2, DnI rfm cfiqRk,[[[[[[ afid iesy iksm dy PONt hn. pr ies qrHF PONts dI dUhrI pRxflI dy afpxy nuksfn hn. iek iksm dy PONts nUM dUsrI iksm ivwc qbdIl nhIN kIqf jf skdf. ies qoN ielfvf pMjfbI PONts dIaF hor vI bhuq sfrIaF smwisafvF hn. kuJ ilpIaF ijvyN anmol ilpI afid nUM ieMtrnYwt qy pfAux bfad awKr iKlr jFdy hn, kuJ hor ivwc dulfvF nfl awDk jF ibMdI afid TIk sQfn qy nhIN pYNdy. iksy PONt ivwc awKr Aupr ibMdI isLPt 'aYc' nwp ky pYNdI hY aqy iksy ivwc isLPt 'afeI' nfl aqy pYr ibMdI vfly awKrF leI qF koeI vI inXm nhIN hY ijQy iksy nUM sUq lwigaf AuQy hI bxf idwqf hY. ies nfl pMjfbI dy iewk vrg dy PONt vI iewk dUsry ivwc qbdIl nhIN ho skdy iswty vjoN vYwbsfeIt aqy vrqoNkfr kol ieko PONt hoxf jLrUrI ho jFdf hY. ies sfry kfsy df iswtf ieh inkldf hY koeI pMjfbI pRqI AuqsLfihq ho ky pMjfbI dI vYwbsfeIt KolHx dI koisLsL krdf hY pr awgoN sfeIt AuWqy Aus nUM gurmuKI awKrF dI QF hor hI GuwgU GoVy ijhy njLr afAuNdy hn aqy Auh aMgryjLI dIaF hor sfeItF vwl clf jFdf hY. hux PONts dy vKryvyN dI smwisaf nfl nijwTx leI XUnIkoz PONt bxfey gey hn. pr ies nUM lfgU krn leI koeI kyNdrI aQfrtI nhIN hY. aKbfr hor PONt vrq rhy hn, kfrz, iesLiqhfr Cfpx vfly hor aqy ieMtrnYwt qy gurmuKI vrqx vfly hor iksm dy PONt vrq rhy hn. pihlF asIN pMjfbI dy sLbd-joVF ivwc ieksfrqf nhIN ilaf sky ijs krky kMipAUtr rfhIN glqIaF nUM afpy TIk krn spell check dI qknIk nUM asIN pMjfbI ivwc lfgU nhIN kr sky. ieQy vI mslf koeI srv pRvfinq aQfrtI nf hox df hI hY. aijhI sMsQf dI bhuq loV hY jo ieMtrnYWt aqy hor qknIkI qbdIlIaF dy mwdynjLr sLbd-joVF aqy PONts ivwc ieksfrqf ilaf sky aqy ieh sfry adfiraF qy lfgU hovy. ies kMm leI srkfr vwloN BfsLf ivBfg, pMjfb dIaF sfrIaF XUnIvristIaF, aKbfrF dy sMpfdkF, kyNdrI lyKk sBfvF aqy sfihq akfdmIaF vrgIaF sMsQfvF dy numfieMidaF qy aDfirq kyNdrI sMsQf bxnI cfhIdI hY ijs dy PYsly srvpRvfinq hox. ies sMsQf nUM ieh vI krnf cfhIdf hY ik pMjfbI PONts dI smwisaf dy hwl leI jo sfPtvyar bxfey jf rhy hn ijvyN ik zf[ gurpRIq isMG lihl, ikrpfl isMG pMnUM jF jnmyjf jOhl vwloN AuhnF nUM KrId ky kMipAUtr qy pMjfbI vrqx vfilaF nUM muPLq idwqy jfx. aijhy Auwdm krky hI kMipAUtr aqy ieMtrnYWt Auwqy pMjfbI BfsLf dI vrqoN nUM AuqsLfihq kIqf jf skdf hY. jy asIN aijhf nhIN kr skdy Bfv pMjfbI BfsLf aqy ilpI nUM ieMtrnYWt aqy kMipAUtr dy hfx dI nhIN kr skdy qF pMjfbI dy ivkfs dIaF gwlF krnIaF bymfienf hn. ies df dUsrf bdl qF iehI bxygf ik ieMtrnYwt Auwqy pMjfbI nUM romn awKrF ivwc hI ilKy jfxf pRvfn kr ilaf jfvy. hux vI pMjfbIaF nfl sbMiDq vYwbsfeItF Auwqy awD nfloN vwD vrqoN romn ilpI dI hI ho rhI hY. pr iPr ieh nf kihxf ik sfmrfj ny sfijLsL krky pMjfbI BfsLf qoN Aus dI ilpI Koh leI hY. inwky-iqwKy: eyar-ieMzIaf dy sPLr 'c hoeI Kwjl-KuafrI sMqoK isMG sMqoK rYizMg ies vyr 2007 dy nvMbr mhIny dI 17 qfrIK ƒ pMjfb jfx leI eyar ieMzIaf dI PlfeIt nMbr ey-vMn 112 lMzn qoN aMimRqsr ‘c sIt buWk krvf leI . biukMg iek mhInf pihlF 18 akqUbr ƒ krvf leI aqy eI-itkt pRfpq kIqI . eI-itkt kMipAUtr ieÈU krdf hY . ijs leI quhfƒ iswDf cYikMg qy phuMcxf huMdf hY nf ik afm itkt vFg 72 GMty pihlF dwsxf jrUrI nhIN hY . ijQy ieh sPr krn vfly leI shUlq hY AuQy ieh hvfeI kMpnI leI vI Pfiedf hY jo jhfj ijMnIaF sItF buwk kr skdy hn. myry pRvfsI jIvn ivc ieh dUjI vfr eyar ieMzIaf dI Auzfn sI . pihlI qy myrI plyTI Auzfn jUn 1962 ivc sI qy ieh djU I 45 sfl bfad 2007 nUM sI . AuNj mYN apRYl 2007 ƒ Bfrq ‘c aMimRqsr qoN idwlI leI sIt buwk kIqI sI jo iek idn pihlF kYNsl ho jfx kfrn sPr jfx qoN vFJf rih igaf sI. 17 nvMbr ƒ lMzn eyarport smfn jFcx qy qolx smyN disaf ik ieh Auzfn idwlI ruk jfxI hY . jdoN mYN ikhf ik myrf itkt qF aMimRqsr df hY . AuhnF df kihxf sI ik AuQy df mOsm TIk nf hox krky sfƒ ieh kYNsl krnI peI hY . ikAuNik aMimRqsr ivc DuMd peI hoeI hY . quhfnMU iPkr krn dI loV nhIN asIN dUsry jhfË ivc quhfƒ aMimRqsr iljfvFgy, AudoN qwk quhfƒ hotl ivc Tihrfieaf jfvygf . sfzf idwlI df stfP quhfzf pUrf iKafl rwKygf . idwlI eyarport qy asIN sO dy krIb XfqrI sF, ijhnF ny aMimRqsr jfxf sI. hvfeI awzy qy BMn-qoV aqy murMmq df kMm cwl irhf sI . nf qF koeI bYTx leI QF sI aqy nf hI eyar ieMzIaf df krmcfrI koeI iËMmyvfrI lY irhf sI . sfzy nfl roVU ryhVI svfrIaF vI sn aqy bwicaF nfl jnfnf svfrIaF vI sn . aqMkvfdIaF dy zr qoN jFc smyN sfrf smfn eyar lfeIn kol jmF sI . sfQoN vI vwD duKI Auh musfiPr sn ijhnF ny inAUXfrk qoN ieh Auzfn PVI sI . asIN GMtf ku Br ieDr AuD r GmuMx qoN bfad slfh krky muV Ausy jhfË ivc cV gey . ijQy sPfeI df kMm cwl irhf sI . Auh bMd ho igaf . sfzy muV jhfË cVn ipCoN eyar ieMzIaf dy sunyhy afAux lwg pey ik jhfË ivcoNbfhr af jfE, quhfnMU nvNy jhfË ivc cVfvFgy . iehnF aPvfhF nfl ivrly ivrly XfqrI jhfË ivcoN Auqrny ÈurU ho gey . koeI do GMty ivc idwlI eyarport qy eyar ieMzIaf dI ieMcfrË Aujflf nF dI lyzI afeI qF asIN Aus nfl gwl kIqI . Aus ny dwisaf ik iksy vI hflq ivc ieh jhfË nhIN jfeygf . asIN nvyN borizMg kfrz ieÈU krny hn . Auh quhfzy purfxy borizMg kfrz dI QF nvIN Auzfn df nMbr hovygf . asIN Aujflf dy nfl hI Auqr afey aqy Aus pfsoN nvyN borizMg kfrz lY ley . sUcnf prdy qy aMimRqsr dI PlfeIt df tfeIm afAuxf ÈurU ho igaf . asIN bysbrI nfl AuzIk krn lwgy . pr kuJ icr bfad Auh sUcnf prdy qoN alop ho geI . sfzf sfiraF df sbr tut cuwkf sI . pihlF do iqMnF ny nfary lfey ik ‘eyar ieMzIaf murdfbfd` Pyr dyKo dyKI sfry ies ivroD ivc Èfiml ho gey . kfPI BIV iekwTI ho geI . nfairaF dy nfl nfl asIN dUjIaF eyar lfeInF dy rsqy rok kr idwqy . ijs nfl eyarport dI sikAuirtI hrkq ivc afeI . qF asIN mohry ho ky ikhf ik pihlF sfzIaF mMgF mMno iPr rsqf CwzFgy . jy qusIN sfƒ PVnf hY qF asIN sfry iqafr hF . AuhnF ny sfzy ivcoN do afdmI gwlbfq leI bulfey . 10 GMty Kwjl-Kuafr hoxqoN bfad aMimRqsr leI sUcnf prdy qy jhfË dI jfxkfrI afeI aqy anfAUNsmYNt kIqI geI . jdoN nfary bfjI cwl rhI sI qF dlyr mihMdI myry kol dI aHMdr lMGx lwgf mYN rok idwqf ik jfxf asIN vI gurU kI ngrI hY, qYƒ sfzf sfQ dyxf cfhIdf hY . pr Auh iksy hor rsqy aMdr cly igaf qy PlfeIt AuhdI vI sfzy vflI hI sI . aMimRqsr iPr Aus nfl gwlbfq hoeI pUry 12 GMty bfad idwlI qoN aMimRqsr leI jhfË ny Auzfn BrI . hux gwl krIey vfpsI vfly vyrvy dI . eyar ieMzIaf dI PlfeIt ey-vn - 111 12 jnvrI nUM svyry y 4·45 df smF sI . jdoN 11 jnvrI dI rfq eyar port qy puwjy qF pqf lwgf ik Auh PlfeIt kYNsl ho geI hY . jdoN eyar ieMzIaf dy stfP nfl gwl kIqI qF AuhnF ny ikhf qusIN kwlH ƒ af ky PlfeIt nMbr ey vn-187 lY skdy ho . sfzy pfs musfiPrF nUM sFBx df koeI ieqMËfm nhIN hY. qusIN vfps ipMz jf skdy ho . asIN quhfzf afAux jfx df ikrfieaf dy dyvFgy . myry Ëor pfAux qy AuhnF ny kMipAUtr ivcoN kYNsl PlfeIt aqy dUjI jfxkfrI vflI PlfeIt df jfxkfrI pwqr dy idwqf aqy Aus AuWqy hwQ nfl ilK idwqf ik afAux jfx df ikrfieaf idwqf jfvygf . hux qwk awDI rfq df vkq h o ckuw f sI . mNY d o iqMn vfr suirMdrbIr ƒ Pon kIqf Auh suwqf hoieaf sI, ies leI tYlIPon nhIN cuwk irhf sI. bfkI dI rfq kwtx leI mYN gurU rfm dfs srF jfx df soicaf . 1957 ivc aMimRqsr ptvfr df iemiqhfn dyx smyN mYN dUjy ividafQIaF nfl cfr idn srF ivc irhf sI . jdoN srF ivc pujy qF kfAUNtr qy iek syvfdfr sI . Aus ny ikhf ik koeI vI kmrf KflI nhIN hY . pr lfgy hI soPy qy iqMn cfr afdmI bYTy sn . Auh kihMdy kmry hYx, sfzy nfl gwl kro qF iml jfxgy . ies qy mYnUM guwsf af igaf . mNY syvfdfr nUM ikhf ik ilK ky dyh ik koeI kmrf KflI nhIN hY . ies nfl bol bulfrf ÈurU ho igaf . Auh aMdroN hor bMidaF ƒ swd ilafieaf . AuhnF ny ikhf ik ies smyN asIN kuJ vI ilK ky nhIN dyxf . eyny ƒ mYN Pyr Pon krky dyiKaf qF suirMdrbIr ny Pon cuwikaf qF Aus pfs afdrÈ ngr rfm qIrQ roz qy jf ky rfq irhf qy tYksI vfly ƒ vfps ipMz Byj idwqf . dUjy idn lOZy vyly dI 3·15 dI PlfeIt sI . siurdM rbIr mnY UM 12 vjy eyarport qy Cwz afieaf . ieh PlfeIt lMzn dI bjfey bRimMGm jfxI sI . smfn qolx lwgy mYN dwisaf ik mYN lMzn dy lfgy rYizMg rihMdf hF . AuQoN lMzn leI kI pRbMD hovygf . ieh quhfƒ bRimMGm ivKy sUicq krFgy ik quhfzf kI ieMqËfm hY . bRimMGm awpV ky jdoN puC pCf ky eyar ieMzIaf df kfAUNtr lwiBaf, AuhnF ny jvfb idwqf ik sfzf koeI ieMqËfm nhIN hY . qusIN afp afpxf ieMqËfm kro qy Gr jf ky klym kr dyxf asIN pYsy dy idaFgy . mNY AuWoN rylvy rfhIN puwjf. ijs nfl vI ies vyr dy sPr dI gwl kIqI hr koeI afp-bIqI dwsx smyN eyar ieMzIaf dI Kwjl KuafrI dy kOVy qËrby dwsy . mYN nvF Èihr dy duafbf kflj dy cyarmYn muihMdr bfT nfl gwl kIqI qF Aus ny itRibAUn dy pihly sPy qy CpI Kbr idKfeI ik ikvNy pUrI dI pUrI PlfeIt 12 GMty qk ieMqËfr krdI rhI . dljIq jOhl mfrksI pfrtI dy nyqf nfl gwl kIqI AuhnF dwisaf ik AuhnF ƒ cfr idn lMzn eyarport qy Kwjl Kuafr hoxf ipaf . zfktr amrjIq isMG jo rYizMg XUnIvristI ivc pRoPYsr irhf hY df kihxf sI ik Auh ikMn y Kq ilK cuwkf hY . pr eyar ieMzIaf nf jvfb idMdf hY aqy nf hI imlx df koeI AulyK hY . ieh sfrIaF gwlF jfnx qoN bfad mYN afpxy KricaF dy vyrvy smyq jdoN mMg pwqr Byijaf qF Auh rijstr zfk rfhIN Byijaf qF ik rsId rhy . ies nfl koeI Prk nhIN ipaf . eyar ieMzIaf df AUT iks krvt bYTdf hY qusIN aMdfjy lfeI jfE . nf Kq imly df vyrvf qy nf kuJ hor . 27 PrvrI nUM mNY rYizMg krfAnU krot ivc Krc y df klym eyar ieMzIaf dy iKlfP kr idqwf . 11 mfrc nUM eyyar ieMzIaf dy vkIl mOrign vfkr qrPoN tYlIPon afieaf ik kys df PYslf kort qoN bfhr hI kr lYNdy hF . mYN ikhf mYnUM koeI ieqrfË nhIN jy myry klym dy pYsy mYƒ idwqy jfx . Aus ny kuJ pYsy Gwt krn leI ikhf qF mYN ikhf ik mYN kort df PYslf dyKFgf . dUsry idn 12 mfrc ƒ AuhnF df mYƒ aqy kort ƒ Kq af gey ik asIN eyar ieMzIaf dI zIPYNs krFgy aqy zIPYNs iqafr krn leI 15 idn dI hor mohlq mMgI . jo kort ny dy idwqI . nfl hI mYƒ tYlIPon afieaf ik mYN klym ivcoN tokn dy qOr qy 10 pONz Gwt lY lvF qF kort qoN bfhr hI kys sYtl ho jfvygf jo mYN nfmnjUr kr idwqf. 15 mfrc n UM mrOign vfkr eyar ieMzIaf dy vkIl df Kq afieaf qy nfl hI sfry kys dI sYtlmYNt dI iebfrq ByjI ik mYN afpxy dsqKq krky ByjF qF Auh cYk Byj dyxgy . jo mNY smo vfr 17 mfrc n UM kro t ivc jf ky idKfieaf aqy dsqKq krky Byj idwqf . iek mhInf bfad 17 aplRY ƒ AuhnF df cYk afieaf hY . jdoN qoNN vfps af ky myrf Kwq pwqr hoieaf hY, ikMny hI aKbfrF ivc kys Cwp cuwky hn . kMpIAUtr itkt df XfqrI aqy kMpnI donF ƒ Pfiedf hY . ijs ansu fr Ahu nF pfs irkfrz hduM f hY . Pyr vI eyar ieMzIaf Evr buikMg kr irhf hY aqy afm lokF ƒ Kwjl Kuafr kr rhy hn . eys vyly jYt eyar lfeIn eyar ieMzIaf nfloN vDIaf srivs dy rhI hY . sfzy lokF ƒ vI cfhIdf hY ik itkt KrIdx smyN eys Kwjl KuafrI qoN bwcx . pwqrkfrI dy bfbf bohV gurbKLsL isMG bMnoafxy ƒ ÈrDFjlI: jo hm py guËrI so guËrI vloN :- surjn ËIrvI gurbÉÈ isMG bMnoafxf AuhnF vicqr pfqrF ivwcoN sI ijhnF ny sfzy kOmI jIvn dy Aus inafry dOr df srgrm sfQ idwqf, jdoN smfjI qy isafsI afdrÈ afpxf muwl rwKdy sn qy jdoN iehnF afdrÈF pRqI byinafË ijhI vÌfdfrI dI afpxI kiÈÈ huMdI sI. Prof: Nirmal Azad: (A radical Punjabi Economist) by:Dr Pritam Singh (Mr. Singh is a Senior Lecturer in Economics at Oxford Brookes University, Oxford, UK.) The death of Professor Nirmal Azad on September 14, 2005 at Patiala brought a tragic end to a turbulent life. His life can be divided into two phases- an early phase, which was creative and productive, and a later phase which, it appears, was troubled and self-destructive. My association with him was primarily during his early phase and my view of him is more influenced by the memories of that phase. I came to know Nirmal when I was studying for my Honours School in Economics degree at Panjab University, Chandigarh where Nirmal had come to study for his Masters in Economics. Along with some other friends, we both got involved in varying degrees with the Maoist movement which had captured the imagination of the idealistic youth all over the world in the late 1960s and the early 1970s. Even at that time Nirmal had an unusually strong individualistic streak in him which did not gel well with the collectivist ethos of the Marxist tradition. Though other friends were very critical of his individualistic streak, I persuaded those friends, though not always successfully, to be more tolerant of him. I treated him with respect and affection and he was more open to suggestions for change when I used to talk to him alone. He confessed to me that he was very influenced by Napoleon’s life which propelled him to adopt an attitude of conquest towards life. This Bonapartist influence did not sit comfortably with the Marxist ethos and though this contradiction seems to have pervaded his entire life, the intellectual attraction of Marxism proved more powerful in his early phase. He passed his MA with first class, taught at Panjab University’s post-graduate centre at Rohtak in Haryana (which later became Maharishi Dayanand University) for a few years and then settled at Punjabi University, Patiala. Born in March 1947, he was the first in his family to have studied at the university like many in his generation. He was proud of the transition he had made from a village life in a backward part of Gurdaspur district to a respectable academic life. He helped many younger members of his large family to acquire higher education and upward social mobility. He showed keen interest in educating his sisters and other girls in the family. He married Balbir, a bold and generous woman with left-wing political orientation, who contributed significantly to sharpening his perspective on gender equality. Nirmal’s politics had a deep impact on many younger members of his family. His younger brother Kulwant and sister Devinder joined the Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPM). Later on after the split in Punjab’s CPM, they joined the CPM (Pasla). One of his cousins Gurmeet was once a leading figure in the pro-Maoist Punjab Students Union, the most powerful student organisation in Punjab in the 1960s and the 1970s. Both Gurmeet and Devinder along with most immediate members of Nirmal’s family have migrated to America. It is, perhaps, a reflection of the tortured nature of Punjabi society and politics since the 1980s that Gurmeet has turned towards religion and Sikh nationalism. If one were to construct a historical profile of Nirmal’s family in the last few decades, it will mirror many trends in Punjabi society concerning rural-urban migration, women’s education, landscape of competing political ideologies and migration to the West. Nirmal’s attachment to his social roots led him to do research on the small peasantry in Punjab and he produced an impressive PhD thesis on the subject. Based on the Leninist method of the differentiation of the peasantry, his work shows scholarly reading on the subject but at the same time reluctance to engage critically with Marxist orthodoxy. When I was studying at Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) and published my first paper on the Italian Marxist Gramsci’s concept of hegemony, he congratulated me but also told me that he did not particularly like my ‘drift’ towards Trotskyism and European Marxism. He did, however, show more openness when he invited me and a group of my ‘Trotskyist’ friends from JNU for a seminar on the Left movement in India under the banner of Marxist Study Forum he had organised in Patiala. Through this Forum, which was the first of its kind in any Punjab city, Nirmal made a leading contribution towards the radicalisation of intellectual and political culture in Patiala. He organised lectures and discussions on contemporary economic and political issues. The left wing scholars who visited Patiala at the invitation of the Marxist Study Forum included Krishna Bharadwaj, Randhir Singh, Prabhat Patnaik, G.S. Bhalla, Utsa Patnaik, T. Shanin and Bipin Chandra. I had accompanied Krishna Bharadwaj, my MPhil supervisor at JNU, to her lecture at Patiala and I remember that she was highly impressed with the level and quality of intellectual exchange she had experienced at her lecture. Nirmal made innovative contributions to curriculum development and research direction at Punjabi University, Patiala. He introduced several radical economics modules to the University’s MA and MPhil programmes. He encouraged his research students to adopt political economy approach in their research perspectives and supervised many PhD, MPhil and MA dissertations. Along with his research and teaching commitments, Nirmal also played a leading role in the trade union work of the Punjabi University Teachers Association. Nirmal also made an effort to broaden his intellectual horizons by academic visits to some leading institutions abroad. He spent 6 months in Warsaw to acquaint himself with the research on the functioning of centrally planned economies and 9 months in Paris to familiarise himself with the research on the revolutionary potentialities of the peasantry. During his stay in Warsaw and Paris, he was a keen observer of the social and political trends in Poland and France. When he came back from Warsaw, he told me that he was struck by the problem of alcoholism in Poland which, he thought, was indicative of some malaise in that society but he also praised the humane methods of the police in picking up drunkards from the streets at night and transporting them to their residences. Nirmal also observed the close proximity between the Catholic Church and the Communists in Poland, and wondered whether in the context of Punjab, Akali-Communist alliance based on the progressive potentialities of the egalitarian teachings of the Sikh Gurus was the most desirable political combine. He was in Paris at the time of the Operation Blue Star and he told me that he was amazed by the ordinary Parisians’ sympathy with Bhindranwale and his comrades in their resistance to the entry of the Indian army into the Golden Temple complex. When I came back from JNU to teach at Panjab University, Chandigarh, Nirmal not only asked me but virtually forced me to write a paper in Punjabi on ‘Imperialism, Indian Capitalism and Punjab Economy’ for a seminar he had organised at Patiala. Later on, he was kind enough to include it as the leading paper in Punjab di Arthikta, a book he edited for Punjabi University, Patiala. This book was the first academic book on Punjab economy in Punjabi. I remain indebted to him for the opportunity he gave me in writing an economics paper in Punjabi because that is the only paper on Punjab economy I have managed to write in Punjabi. What I admired most in Nirmal was that he wrote extensively on Punjab economy for Punjabi language newspapers. In order to reach as broad and diverse readership as possible, he wrote for newspapers with varying ideological orientations. These included the Punjabi nationalist Ajit, the Hindu nationalist Jag Bani, the ideologically ambiguous Punjabi Tribune, the pro-CPM Desh Sevak and the Sikh nationalist Aj Di Awaz. Through his writings in these newspapers, he has not only contributed to enhancing the understanding of Punjab economy among the readers of these newspapers, he has also contributed to the enrichment of Punjabi language and its modern scientific vocabulary. It might not be an exaggeration to say that of all Punjabi academics, it was Nirmal whose writings reached the largest number of readers in Punjab through his contributions to the Punjabi newspapers. His contribution to economic journalism in Punjabi will be difficult to surpass in the near future. My friend Amarjit Chandan, the London based Punjabi poet, has reminded me about Nirmal’s interest in Punjabi poetry. Many of Nirmal’s poems have been published in Punjabi newspapers and magazines. Chandan also remembers Nirmal’s ‘jatki’ (peasant) sense of humour. According to Chandan who met Nirmal in Patiala a few years ago, when he saw the photographs of Lenin, Bhagat Singh and Bhindranwale on the walls of his ‘rather grand office’, he thought that that summed up Nirmal’s personality. I guess that the appeal these three different types of historical figures had for Nirmal was that all of them subscribed to some version of the voluntarist conception of historical change. The earlier Bonapartist influence was finding new manifestations. Nirmal contributed many articles on different dimensions of the Punjab economy to journals and edited books. He valued highly the exchange of opinions and views with fellow academics and political activists. When my first article was published in Economic and Political Weekly in 1983, Nirmal wrote a letter of appreciation from Paris and also conveyed the appreciation of the article by Ashok Rudra, a leading left wing Indian economist, who was also a visiting academic in Paris then. Nirmal was as generous in appreciation as he was harsh in condemnation. He alienated many people, including some of his friends and well wishers, by the harshness with which he sometimes treated them. My friend Professor Birinder Pal Singh from Patiala, who informed me about Nirmal’s death, also gave me one piece of information about Nirmal which was not previously known. A few months ago before his death, Nirmal had quietly expressed a wish in a letter to the university authorities that all of his provident fund earnings and the books be donated to the Punjabi University Library. It seems that this letter was later on withdrawn. It looks as if he was grappling with the conflicting pulls of the self and the collective. He seemed to be wanting to have a last shot at dialectics. Perhaps, he wanted to convert his loneliness, alienation and social isolation into social commitment. (This is a slightly revised version of the obituary published in the Journal of Punjab Studies, Vol.12, No 2) lfl isMG idl ny afpxy nvyN kfiv-sMgRih ‘bhuq sfry sUrj` dI iek kfpI ‘muhwbq nfl zf: hirBjn leI ByjI hY, aYn AuhnIN idnIN jdoN lok iek dUjy ƒ nvyN sfl dI vDfeI kfrz Byjdy hn. inAUË ipRMt dy myl df GsmYlf ijhf kfÊË, ikqy loVoN vD gUVHI isafhI dy pUMJy qy ikqy loVoN Gtf-mwDr isafhI dy bymlUm ijhy Dwby. srvrk qoN ipTvrk qk ies df koeI vI nkÈ aYsf nhIN jo vyKx-pVHn vfly ƒ afpxy vwl sYxq krdf hovy. myrf jI nhIN sI krdf ik swT ku siÌaF dI ies ikqfbVI ƒ huMMgfrf dyvyN. qF kI nvyN sfl dI ies ‘muhwbq nfl` ByjI hoeI sugfq ƒ nFh ikvyN kr idaF. afpxy suBf muqfibk mYN ies df vfk lYNdf hF. ikqfb boldI hY: 1[ 1[ pMzq jvfhr lfl nihrU AuhnIN idnIN nfisk jyl ivwc sn. kYdIaF nUM Kfx leI jo rotIaF imilaf krdIaF sn, AunHF ivwc imwtI imlI hoeI huMdI sI. iewk idn nihrU jI ny ies bfry jyl dy suprzYNt kol isLkfieq kIqI,’’ieh rotIaF ikvyN KfDIaF jf skdIaF hn? ienHF ivwc imwtI imlI hoeI ey.’’ iek vfr iek gF, sUr, qy Koqy ny iek mulk `coN Bwj jfx df PYslf kIqf, ikAuNik AuQy AuhnF ƒ iZwz BrvF Kfx ƒ nhIN sI imldf. alock smuMdr vwl sPLr AuWqy jf irhf GoVsvfr iek rfq sVk dy iknfry iewk srF ivwc puwjf, Auhny drvfjLy kol iewk drwKLq nfl GoVy nUM bMinHaf aqy srF ivwc pRvysL kr igaf . awDI rfq nUM jdoN sfry sON rhy sn qF iewk cor afieaf aqy musfPr df GoVf corI kr ky lY igaf . svyry AuWTx AuWqy XfqrI nUM afpxy GoVy dy corI ho jfx df pqf lwgf. Auh bhuq duKI hoieaf aqy Aus afdmI nUM mn hI mn burf-Blf kihx lwgf, ijs dy mn ivwc GoVy nUM corI krn df iKafl afieaf . srF ivwc Aus nfl Tihry dUjy afdmI vI AuWQy iekwTy ho gey qy gwlF krn lwgy. pihly afdmI ny ikhf, ‘GoVy nUM asqbl dy bfhr bMnHxf ikMnI vwzI mUrKqf hY.` dUjf afdmI boilaf, ‘hwd hY, GoVy dy agly pYrF nUM bMinHaf jf skdf sI.` qIjy ny ikhf, ‘GoVy AuWpr eyny lMmy sPr `qy inklxf hI nf-smJI hY. cOQf boilaf, ‘kmjLor qy aflsI lok hI svfrI leI GoVf rwKdy hn. musfPr nUM bVI hYrfnI hoeI, pRMqU Auh afpxy afp AuWqy kfbU nf rwK sikaf qy boilaf, Brfvo! ikAuNik myrf GoVf corI ho igaf hY, ies leI qusIN sfry myrIaF glqIaF qy kmIaF dwsx leI Auqfvly ho. hYrfnI hY, GoVf curfAux vfly afdmI dy gYr-kfnUMnI kMm bfry quhfzy lokF dy mUMhoN iek sLbd vI nhIN inkilaf.` -KlIl ijbrfnsfrIaF rfjnIqk pfrtIaF aKLIr ivwc afpxf hI JUT ingl ky mr jFdIaF hn. - jOn afrbrnft |